In response to Pahalgam attack on 22 April 2025, India held the Indus Waters Treaty, 1960 (the Treaty) in ‘abeyance’. In so doing, India purportedly suspended or terminated the Treaty and all its operations. Pakistan petitioned the Court of Arbitration, constituted under the Treaty, (the Court) to determine the ‘status of the Treaty’ after India’s unilateral act of suspension or termination. On 31 August 2026, the Court issued the award (the Award) where it held that India’s act of ‘abeyance’ has no basis under the Treaty or international law. Significantly, the Court, through the Award, has effectively moved suspension and termination of the Treaty from India’s framework of terrorism to framework of International Human Rights Law (IHRL).
The Court ruled that since scope of the Treaty is limited to “use of the waters of the Rivers and matters incidental thereto” (Article XI (1) of the Treaty), any alleged act of terrorism does not amount to material breach of the Treaty justifying its suspension or termination, nor does it justify countermeasures that would adversely affect human rights of the people of Pakistan. The Court reached said conclusion even upon assuming, for argument’s sake, that India’s allegations were true.
The Court held that unilateral suspension or termination of the Treaty by India appears to be a claim that India no longer has obligation to let Western Rivers flow into Pakistan or Pakistan-administered territory. Such “withholding or diversion” of Western Rivers would have serious effects on the human rights and subsistence of the people of Pakistan. The Court relied upon correspondence to India by UN Special Rapporteurs from October 2025, in which it is stated with grave concern that any disruption of the flow of water to Pakistan “could severely affect the human rights of millions of people in Pakistan who rely on the river for agriculture, industry, drinking water and sanitation, and healthy ecosystems”. The Court noted that rights identified by the Special Rapporteurs, i.e. the rights to water, food, an adequate standard of living and a healthy environment, are generally accepted as “fundamental human rights”.
The Court went on to conclude that “since India’s decision on abeyance is likely to result in interference with the enjoyment by the people of Pakistan of fundamental human rights, such a decision cannot be considered a lawful countermeasure.”
India, in the past, has expressed concerns that countermeasures could be “open to serious abuse” if not restricted carefully and that a state should not act as “judge in its own cause”. In the event of disagreement between two States, India has previously maintained that the matter may be resolved through resort to available dispute settlement procedures. Moreover, India, being party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) since 1979, is bound by fundamental human rights enshrined in both Covenants.
Although India deems the Treaty as suspended or terminated and rejects any proceedings before the Court and its judgments, India is nonetheless bound by its obligations under IHRL. Under Article 1(2) of both Covenants, all peoples have the right to freely dispose of their natural resources and “In no case may a people be deprived of its own means of subsistence”. Article 11 of ICESCR recognises the right of everyone to an adequate standard of living and that States Parties are obligated to take steps to ensure realization of this right. Article 12 stipulates that everyone has the right to enjoy the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health. The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in its General Comment No.15 (2002) relied upon the foregoing Articles to derive ‘right to water’ of individuals and state obligation to “respect the enjoyment of the right in other countries”. Accordingly, States Parties, including India, are obligated to refrain from imposing measures that “prevent the supply of water” and water cannot be used as “an instrument of political and economic pressure”.
Building on the Award, Pakistan should now challenge the abeyance of the Treaty in forums established under IHRL, including the UN Human Rights Council (with its Universal Periodic Review and Special Rapporteurs) and committees monitoring implementation of ICCPR and ICESCR. This would allow framing of questions concerning flow of waters under the Treaty in the narrative of human rights protection, displacing India’s narrative of alleged cross-border terrorism. It is noteworthy that any findings by the international human rights forums regarding ‘right to water and related human rights’ might not be binding and enforceable against India. However, this gives Pakistan the leverage to argue its case with a moral and legal high ground in the realm of international politics and diplomacy.
